Understanding Pass-Through Capital Gains from Mutual Funds

As financial advisors, we often encounter a lot of questions between November and the end of tax season related to pass-through capital gains from mutual funds held in taxable brokerage accounts. Before we jump into the mechanics, investment strategies, and tax consequences of pass-through capital gains from mutual funds, it’s important to understand exactly what capital gains are, and what types of accounts and funds this issue applies to.

What Are Pass-Through Capital Gains?

Capital gains are realized any time you sell an investment and realize a gain on the sale.

For example, if I purchase a share of stock for $100, and 2 years later I sell it for $120, I will realize $20 in capital gains. If the stock is held in a taxable account, and I’ve held the stock for at least 1 year, this $20 in gain will be taxed at my long-term capital gains rate.

Pass-through capital gains in mutual funds work similarly in that they represent gain realized when a stock position is sold in a mutual fund. However, in this case, the gain is realized by the mutual fund company that sells the stock and then, at the end of the year, that gain is passed on proportionately to the shareholders of the mutual fund.

How does this work for you (a shareholder of the mutual fund)?

Let’s say, over the course of the year, the managers of Imaginary Friend Mutual Fund (imaginary ticker IMFRX) sell 20% of the stocks in the fund, and realize $500,000 in long term capital gains. If IMFRX investors own 1,000,000 shares when the capital gains distribution is made, each share would have a capital gain of $0.50 passed through to it ($500,000/1,000,000) and if you owned 700 shares of IMFRX, you would have $350 ($0.50*700) in realized long-term capital gains, even though you never bought or sold anything in your account. This gain was simply passed through to you as a part-owner of the fund.

What Types of Accounts Are Impacted?

Pass through capital gains from mutual funds happen in all accounts, but they really only matter in accounts that are considered taxable brokerage accounts.

These include:

  • Individual Brokerage Accounts
  • Joint Tenants or Community Property Accounts
  • UGMA or UTMA custodial accounts for kids

They do not matter in tax-deferred accounts, like IRAs, Roth IRAs, 401ks, or HSAs.

Though these accounts still experience pass-through capital gains, due to their tax structure, the capital gains do not need to be reported by the investor on their tax return each year.

What Types of Funds Actually Pass-through Gains?

Although there are many types of blended or pooled investments, Exchange Traded Funds, also known as ETFs, and Mutual Funds are the most common types of pooled funds owned by everyday investors.

For practical purposes it makes sense to think of these funds somewhat interchangeably in terms of the investment objective they accomplish. But when we’re talking about the question of pass-through capital gains, we’re almost always talking about mutual funds. (For those who want to be particular about the details, it’s not that ETFs aren’t required to pass through capital gains, but because of the way they trade, they rarely do).

If you’re not sure whether you own mutual funds or ETFs, an easy way to tell is to look at the ticker symbol. For mutual funds, it will always be a 5 letter ticker symbol that ends in X. For ETFs, the number of letters in the ticker is typically less than 5, and they generally do not end in X.

For example, if you own a Vanguard S&P 500 mutual fund, you’ll see the ticker symbol VFIAX, but if you own a Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, you’ll see the ticker symbol VOO. And while these two funds are serving a functionally equivalent investment objective, only VFIAX is likely to have any pass-through capital gains, and that only matters if it’s held in a taxable, non-retirement brokerage account.

Why Should We Care About Pass-Through Capital Gains?

Pass-through capital gains show up on your tax return and you will owe taxes on them, most commonly at your long-term capital gains rate.

This may not be a huge deal if we’re only talking about $350 in gains, as we encountered in our Imaginary Friend Mutual Fund example above.

But for larger accounts, and for individuals who are trying to do appropriate tax planning (especially if they have specific tax objectives in mind that require an accurate income estimate), anticipating and/or avoiding pass-through capital gains is important to get an overall sense of your taxable income and tax obligations.

Is There Any Way to Predict Pass-Through Capital Gains?

Yes and no. Early in the year, it is truly anybody’s guess how much capital gains an individual mutual fund is likely to pass through, though funds that trade actively, and have a high turnover rate in investments, are usually going to be more likely to pass through higher amounts of gain to investors. But there are other variables at play as well, like overall market performance, and how many current shareholders exit the fund (which often forces a sale of underlying investments) that are impossible to predict. However, in late October or November, most mutual fund companies start posting and informing investors about the anticipated Capital Gains payout, which often happens early to mid-December. On the day this payout occurs, you’ll typically see that payout in your account, AND you’ll see the price of the mutual fund drop by exactly as much as the gain payout.

So, an investor who knows what to watch for, and who really needs that information before the end of the year, can typically get it from being watchful of their taxable investment accounts in November and December, and should be able to make a pretty accurate prediction about total pass-through capital gains. But the official record is not sent out to you until you receive your consolidated 1099 tax form in late January or February.

Do You Actually Realize More Capital Gains on Mutual Funds than on ETFs?

This is probably one of the biggest myths about mutual funds vs. ETFs. Because ETFs don’t pass through capital gains, they are often considered more tax-efficient, which many people interpret to mean, you pay fewer taxes on them. In reality, they are actually more tax-predictable, which could lead to higher tax-efficiency, but it depends a lot on your tax situation.

You don’t actually realize MORE gain or pay MORE taxes on mutual funds, so much as, because mutual funds distribute some of their gains each year, based on things sold within the fund, you end up paying some capital gains tax each year on those gains (but that is capital gains tax you won’t be paying later). The biggest issue is, you don’t really have any control over when those gains occur.

If you own an ETF, you would in most cases never actually realize a capital gain until the day you choose to sell the ETF, but because the ETF hasn’t been distributing a little bit of its gains to you each year, at that point, you’ll realize all of the gain the ETF has incurred since you purchased it.

For a simplified example of how this works, let’s pretend there is a PQRSX mutual fund which is functionally equivalent in its investment objective to ABC, which is an ETF. 

So just because ABC is an ETF, it isn’t inherently going to realize fewer gains, but you can delay realizing those gains (and therefore paying those taxes) for longer. You have more control over when you realize the gain and when you have to pay the taxes on it.  

Is there a way to avoid these pass-through capital gains in taxable accounts?

It depends.

If you’re just setting up a taxable brokerage account for the first time, by choosing ETFs rather than mutual funds for your pooled investments, you’ll be choosing an investment structure that is inherently a lot less likely to pass through any capital gains to its investors. You’ll still be on the hook for the capital gains realized when you sell the shares, but you won’t have to deal with the annual prediction and anticipation of how much gain will be passed through to you.

On the other hand, if you already own a lot of mutual funds in your brokerage account, it’s unlikely that you can just sell off all of your mutual funds and replace them with ETFs without realizing a substantial amount of capital gains in the year that you make that swap. So, you’d have to analyze whether or not taking a short-term tax hit and realizing a bunch of capital gains now is actually worth it to avoid the unpredictable nature of pass-through capital gains in the future.

Alternatively, if a total swap (and the big, immediate capital gains that could come with it) isn’t desirable for your current tax situation, you might look at employing a strategy where new money and new investments are put into ETFs, and you live with trying to predict and accommodate the pass-through gains on your existing investments.

What do pass-through capital gains mean for you?

Depending on your account and tax strategy, pass-through capital gains could mean nothing to you (this would be true of someone who, for example, only has investments in retirement accounts), or they could be a real headache for you every tax season (which could be the case if you have a large taxable brokerage account invested mostly in actively traded mutual funds). Now that we’ve reviewed what pass-through capital gains are, how they work, and what the tax consequences are, it’s up to you to decide what makes sense for you. If you’re still left scratching your head, feel free to schedule a free 30-min call with us and we’ll try to fill in the gaps!